Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
Post Info TOPIC: Nascar losing its competition


Nathan Helton
Former Member


Status: Offline
Posts: 621
Date:
Nascar losing its competition


Found this on Yahoo

BROOKLYN, Mich. – Without question, competition is the lifeblood of NASCAR – be it from behind the wheel, along pit road, watching from the stands or in front of a TV.

Without it, we might as well be playing tiddlywinks or cross-stitching cardigan sweaters. B-o-r-i-n-g.

Because the sport is so competition-driven, with high speeds, daring and dicing maneuvers between cars, and yes, the invariable crashes, it's no mystery why NASCAR has grown into the second most popular sport in the U.S., with some of the most diehard and devoted fans in all of sports.

Yet NASCAR has a problem that, unless it changes soon, could lead to a nasty negative backlash from those fans – and some teams – in the very near future.

I'm referring to the sheer domination this season by just two teams: Roush Racing and Hendrick Motorsports. Heading into Sunday's Batman Begins 400 at Michigan International Speedway, the Roush and Hendrick organizations have combined to win 12 of the first 14 races.  Those two teams are blowing away the competition, and NASCAR may need to do something about it.

For those keeping score at home: Roush has seven wins (including four by Greg Biffle) and Hendrick has five (including three by Jeff Gordon). Combined, the teams are winning at a nearly 86-percent clip.

Yes, 86 percent! That's almost as high as the house's winning percentage at a casino. Ask any bookie and he'll tell you picking against Roush or Hendrick winning is a sucker's bet.

It's enough to make fans of other teams and drivers – let alone the actual teams and drivers themselves – become increasingly discouraged week after week as yet another Roush or Hendrick driver motors into victory lane.

With 22 races left in the season, and more importantly, just 12 races left to qualify for the Chase for the Nextel Cup, the list of notable drivers not from the Roush or Hendrick camps who have yet to win a race this season reads like a who's who: Tony Stewart, Dale Earnhardt Jr., Bobby Labonte, Dale Jarrett, Elliott Sadler, Ryan Newman, Rusty Wallace, Jamie McMurray and Ricky Rudd.

Usually by this point in the season, a few of those guys would have collected at least one win. Only Richard Childress Racing's Kevin Harvick (Bristol) and Evernham Motorsports' Kasey Kahne (Richmond) have managed to keep Roush or Hendrick out of victory lane on any given weekend.

Don't get me wrong, I'm not knocking the Roush or Hendrick organizations. I give them credit for finding various ways to take the checkered flag, with much of the reason for their success being their ability to master this season's new spoiler/tire combination better than any other organization.

But having a Roush or Hendrick car in victory lane week after week after week is starting to become, well, pick a word: mundane, dull, routine, commonplace, unexciting, humdrum, monotonous, tedious, uninteresting …

Or perhaps the best word truly is "boring."

NASCAR chairman Brian France and president Mike Helton should be very concerned. Because they seemingly have smarter engineers and crew chiefs right now, the Roush and Hendrick camps not only are winning but also are inadvertently doing damage to the sport.

If the Roush/Hendrick dominance continues, fans of other teams and drivers soon may turn their loyalties away, feeling the sport isn't fun anymore. And if other drivers don't think they have a chance to win, the No. 1 element that has made stock car racing so popular – intense competition – will be diminished.

There's no easy solution to the problem. How do you keep a certain organization from winning without sheer and utter discrimination against them? How can you penalize someone for winning too much? Intentionally stacking the deck against a certain team or organization wouldn't be fair.

But there is one possibility. If there ever were a time for NASCAR to contemplate limiting organizations to two or three cars/teams to make things more competitive and give more drivers a chance to win, now is obviously that time.

Does Jack Roush really need five Nextel Cup teams? Can't Rick Hendrick get by with only two or three Cup teams?

More cars per team means more information gained and shared, and more chances to win. Limiting the number of cars per stable could curb a team's strength.

Sure, NASCAR is as much a business as it is a sport. And if business generates opportunity, that typically translates into more cars. But at some point, NASCAR as a sanctioning body has to step in and tell organizations and sponsors that they have to spread the wealth around.

Otherwise, if things continue going the way they are now, don't be surprised if teams that continue to be shut out of victory lane begin closing up shop and, like their fans, start fading away.

Winning is the fun part of racing. As the old saying goes, to the victors go the spoils.

But what fun is it if you can't win because the other guys have a stranglehold on success that they won't give up?


 


  Anybody remember the year that Winston Cup went the 1st 15 races and had 15 different winners. I dont remember what year but I know it happened one year. Bet we dont see that happen again.

 

  Helton 



-- Edited by Helton at 01:14, 2005-06-17

-- Edited by Helton at 01:16, 2005-06-17

__________________
Good Luck and Have Fun
RTI #81 #82 #83 #84


Labonte MotorSports

Status: Offline
Posts: 222
Date:

there is no problem there

__________________
truckmanager@thecoolpool.com


Matt Sealey
Former Member


Status: Offline
Posts: 3690
Date:

the guy that wrote that article sounded intelligent, yet the whole idea was just stupid.  in the mid-nineties, there was this young upstart that dominated 3 years in a row with at least 10 wins each year and the sport still managed to grow into what it has become today.


the real reason people should be concerned is the caution laps. 17% of laps driven this year have been caution laps, thats 775 laps people!!! I think the fewest we have had in any given week has been 9 and thats the most we had at any particular week last year by this time.


between tire wear, new spoiler and gear rules, and just downright impatience on the track, there has been way too many cautions thus far.



__________________


Lou Demian - President

Status: Offline
Posts: 8032
Date:

Hey, I'm not a huge fan of Rousch and definately not a fan of Hendrick, but according to this writer.... why should you penalize someone because they are winning too much? That's just crazy... forcing teams to cut back to 2-3 cars because some other team with more resources is doing better?


That's like telling those dynasty teams of the Yankees and chicago Bulls that....  Hey baseball fans and basketball fans are sick of seeing you two guys winning all the time so we're gonna take some of your good players away to even the playing field.


Why don't you concentrate on not limiting these 2 organziations, but telling the others to step it up a notch so that they can compete??



__________________

2013 Cup Series Champion

2005, 2009, 2011, 2016 Xfinity Series Champion

2008 & 2010 Truck Series Champion

2007, 2012 & 2013 Streak to the Finish Champion





Steve Dutko

Zipperhead Racing
Former Member


Status: Offline
Posts: 410
Date:

Stupid liberal article from Yahoo again. Instead of trying to raise the poor(RCR,JGR) to reach the status of the middle class or rich(Hendrick,Roush) they love to attack the rich. You have too much money(wins) so me must take from you and give to those that don't. Never works never will.


That's why it called competion. This year its Roush and maybe next its Joe Gibbs racing. Teams will learn and catch up.



__________________


Nathan Helton
Former Member


Status: Offline
Posts: 621
Date:

I think it all comes down to money, I agree that you should not tell a team to stop winning so much. But look at the NFL and what they have done with the cap. It keeps teams from buying a super bowl because imagine a team that could pay out millions of dollars for any player. They could have a team made up of totaly pro-bowlers. And NFL is the #1 sport in America, We have seen the teams have thier run and then someone else takes over, Pittsburgh had thier run,Dallas, San Francisco, Denver and New England is finishing thiers with all thier coches going to other teams. I hate to say it but Nascar has taking the road paved by Indy, Money wins the races. Look at it this way, Its great for guys like us because it makes it easier for Fantasy teams to pick drivers when only two teams in Nextell are winning races.


  Good Luck


  Helton       



__________________
Good Luck and Have Fun
RTI #81 #82 #83 #84


Lou Demian - President

Status: Offline
Posts: 8032
Date:

Well you do have a point there, Helton. Money does win races. Roush and Hendrick have the most money so yeah, they are gonna win. However, it's the drivers and teams too. Biffle is having a banner year, but how is Matt Kenseth doing? The 2003 champ is pretty much down the toilet this year. They have the same resources as all the other Roush cars. Bobby Labonte.. 2000 champ. Where is he now? Barely in the top 35. They don't have the same money and resources they had back in 2000? They have even more now since they have a 3rd car. Even Tony Stewart and last year's champ Kurt Busch are having their problems this year. Every driver is gonna have is up and down years. This year it's Greg Biffle and Jimmie Johnson who are having great years. And so because they are winning, their organizations should be penalized?


If NASCAR wants to help level things out, maybe they should look for ways to save team costs so that teams can put their excess money into testing and research.


One way perhaps is to maybe have the limited tire rule like they have in the Busch Series. Save a lot of money right there with how much tires cost.



__________________

2013 Cup Series Champion

2005, 2009, 2011, 2016 Xfinity Series Champion

2008 & 2010 Truck Series Champion

2007, 2012 & 2013 Streak to the Finish Champion





Matt Sealey
Former Member


Status: Offline
Posts: 3690
Date:

I don't advise adopting any Busch rules..........those races are so Boring! If it weren't for the young guns coming up, I wouldn't watch them at all.


as for the money winning races? nope, don't think so as Intimidator pointed out.


what wins races? it has alot to do with LUCK. after that, it really is team chemistry. DEI has just as much money as they had last year, and yet they struggle this year because of all the personell changes. what teams are winning? the #6, #48, #24, #99, #16...............all have teams that work well within the ranks and with their teammates.



__________________


Labonte MotorSports

Status: Offline
Posts: 222
Date:

the thing is hendrick and roush have more tests and the teams allways have and allways will share their testing information so if nascar really wants to even them out even the amount of tests a team can take as a whole and see how much domination there is

__________________
truckmanager@thecoolpool.com


Matt Sealey
Former Member


Status: Offline
Posts: 3690
Date:

LM, that was the second best idea that you've had since joining up in this community board!

__________________


Labonte MotorSports

Status: Offline
Posts: 222
Date:

what was first?

__________________
truckmanager@thecoolpool.com


Matt Sealey
Former Member


Status: Offline
Posts: 3690
Date:

LOL, I knew you would ask that..............the Truck League!



__________________
Page 1 of 1  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.

Tweet this page Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us


Create your own FREE Forum
Report Abuse
Powered by ActiveBoard